Beautiful recording! Charted at #54 on Billboard Hot 100 in May 1964. Although the chart placing in the U.S. wasn't too high, this recording was an international hit and much more popular in other countries such as Canada (it charted at #2 on the CHUM chart), Lucille's native country.
Charted at #7 on Billboard Hot 100 in October 1960, and #1 on Billboard RB chart. The title of this song was changed to "He Don't Love You (Like I Love You)" when Tony Orlando and Dawn remade it in the '70's.
"He" was a hit for a few different artists in 1955. I don't know when this version was recorded but I labeled it 1955 since the song was a hit that year and also because it was the song that the Lennon Sisters sang on "The Lawrence Welk Show" on their first appearance in 1955. Listen to the angelic harmonies.